Showing posts with label England rugby. Show all posts
Showing posts with label England rugby. Show all posts

Friday, November 20, 2015

England rugby faces a long haul back

It's official – Eddie Jones' appointment has completed what has long been suspected – England Rugby have run out of ideas.

It shouldn't be a surprise. It's the same in most other aspects of their sport, and possibly even their commercial and other fields.

The country that gave the world many of their competitive sports while spreading their Empire around the world has admitted defeat. They can't do it on their own.

So what are we going to see?

Will we see a distinctive England style of rugby, a style capable of putting the good old red rose back where it belongs? Hardly.

Will we see an England united to the point where it sweeps all before it in an on-going demonstration of dominance such as the All Blacks have just completed? Unlikely.

Will England's players suddenly unleash skills, consistently and for 80 minutes, that have hitherto lain dormant allowing them to overcome all odds and enjoy a sustained period of success? Difficult to believe.

Why?

England is like South Africa. Its internal politics always let it down when it comes to the crunch.

Consider what happened to the Springboks this year, and every time they get to a vital stage of their season.

Someone with a political axe to grind emerges from the woodwork to claim race quotas are not being met and there needs to be some action to ensure they are.

It's a constant weight on their game and can't help but cause destabilisation in their side. Japan's win over South Africa this year is a classic example of that.

England are no different. They can't get their team together long enough to understand what their requirements are. What a waste of time and money it was sending their team to the high altitude of Colorado to supercharge their fitness for their campaign.

Who is advising them of this sort of rubbish? Where was the All Blacks' need for high altitude training? Where did Australia have their pre-tournament time together? At Notre Dame, slap bang in the middle of the American prairie, no altitude training there.

And then there are their clubs. It's a situation tailor-made for disaster, just like their football, just like their cricket.

In reality Wales, Ireland and Scotland are little better.

With the introduction of professional leagues, there are any number of chances for home-grown coaches to learn in the white-hot atmosphere those competitions generate.

But it is clear something is rotten in the state of Denmark.

Why have none of these countries developed and sustained a coaching pyramid?

Is it down to interference from administrators and board members who think they know best?

That has to be suspected. It's all about results, yet it isn't.

How can you achieve success when everyone is sticking their oar in?

All of this without even starting to think about the role of their media in this whole charade – that's completely another story.

Sympathy has to be extended to those coaches who are being denied their right to learn at the highest levels for the betterment of the game in their regions.

Sport should be an expression of the culture of the team playing whatever game is involved just as the All Blacks represent the New Zealand style, and Brazil represent the style and flair of their country, and as the basketballing dream teams of the United States represent all that is glitz and glamour of their country.

Sadly, Home Nations rugby is doomed to be only a variation on a theme, a Southern Hemisphere theme.

What a World Cup it will be when the world's top nations come together and play rugby that best represents their respective countries. That would be the greatest World Cup of all.


But clearly it is going to be a long time coming.

Thursday, November 12, 2015

What is it that England don't understand?

What is it about the English psyche that doesn't get it?

In all respects it seems to be, 'we can't do it ourselves, let's whistle up someone else to sort it out'.

Now they are looking for some overseas coach to sort out their rugby team. Don't they realize that the four semi-finalists at the 2015 Rugby World Cup were all coached by coaches from those countries. They didn't need a foreign coach.

Who would want to take the England job on?

There is no practical control by The Rugby Union over their clubs, so there is none of the unity in the structure of the game that most other countries enjoy.

This is a direct result of the 'We know best' attitude that occurred when rugby went professional in 1996. This, in spite of all the examples available in professional sports in Britain at the time.

Instead, what has developed is a culture that clubs come first and for clubs it is all about winning.

They don't share the constitutional demand of all national bodies that they exist to develop the game in their countries.

So while winning remains the be-all and end-all for the clubs, they import players from overseas, generally in the least productive phases of their careers, instead of nurturing home grown talent.

The result? Pre-play-offs departures from Rugby World Cups hosted on their home grounds or in the case of a similar cot-case France, a thrashing in the quarter-finals.

The evidence of the narrow benefit of this type of approach is there to see in football and cricket for starters. How long since England won the World Cup in football? 1966. How long since the won the World Cup in cricket? Never.

Now the cure-all for their rugby performances is to hire an overseas coach.

Let's remember a couple of points.

Sir Clive Woodward wasn't everyone's cup of tea. But he knew what made English rugby tick. He survived a horrendous introduction and then moved heaven and earth to get what he wanted to ensure his side won the 2003 Rugby World Cup.

Lost to the game, he was replaced by one of his fellow coaches in the 2003 campaign Andy Robinson. He won nine games out of 22. Not good enough they said so out he went. Bring in Brian Ashton for the World Cup in 2007 and while they made it to the final, one prominent player said recently that for the life of him he couldn't work out how they actually achieved that.

Because they performed so lamentably in 2007 why not appoint the man who captained the team to their victory in 2003 Martin Johnson?

Right idea, but wrong time. Johnson had nothing like the sort of coaching experience necessary to do the job.

As a result the side he brought to New Zealand for the 2011 World Cup was quickly found to be dysfunctional, and they played on and off-the-field, accordingly.

But both Ashton and Johnson had win ratios of 55 percent.

Bring in a new coach, Stuart Lancaster who managed a 61 percent win ratio, and out he goes.

An interesting fact is that Woodward (in 83 Tests, 33 more than any other England coach) had a 71 percent win ratio and his two predecessors Geoff Cooke (50 Tests) and Jack Rowell (29 Tests) each had a 72 percent win ratio.

Surely that shows that the best person in charge of England's rugby should be an Englishman?

After his experience in England rugby, All Black player and selector Earle Kirton always said: "When England get it right, watch out!"

The comforting thing for the rest of the world is that in spite of all their resources England have an unfailing knack for getting it wrong.


And all the signs point to them doing it again.