Showing posts with label Colin Meads. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colin Meads. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 15, 2020

Hard man lists contain many omissions

At a time when sports news outlets are struggling for content, list-making becomes much more prevalent.

And imagination has certainly been fired up in efforts to stay engaged with their readership.

It is ultimately an exercise in futility as most lists involve comparing generations and choices that will never be tested in the white heat of combat.

Everyone has their reasons for making their choices and they are often more interesting than the choices themselves.

One especially difficult group of lists has been doing the rounds this week, the choice of the 'hardest' players in rugby.

Inevitably, selections tend to be about as deep as the owner's memory which can be 20 years or 40 years.

s

But rugby was being played a long time before that.

Two lists this week have been completed by Stuart Barnes and Graham Price, both British & Irish Lions, from England and Wales respectively.

Barnes' top 10 was: Gareth Chilcott (England), Gerard Cholley (France), Jonny Wilkinson (England), Graham Price (Wales), Eben Etzebeth (South Africa), Wayne Shelford (New Zealand), David Pocock (Australia), Richie McCaw (New Zealand), Scott Gibbs (Wales), Jim Telfer (Scotland).

Price's list was: Cholley, Michel Palmie (France), Alain Esteve (France), Colin Meads (New Zealand), Frank Oliver (New Zealand), Fran Cotton (England), Shelford, Jerry Collins (New Zealand, Bakkies Botha (South Africa), Etzebeth.

For what it's worth, some notable omissions would appear to be: Alex Wyllie (New Zealand), Alain Plantefol (France), Mark Shaw (New Zealand), Morne du Plessis (South Africa), Sebastian Chabal (France), Ken Gray (New Zealand), Mervyn Davies (Wales), Bismarck du Plessis (South Africa), Kevin Skinner (New Zealand), Chris Koch (South Africa), Keith Murdoch (New Zealand) and that's without dipping back into the pre-World War Two era.

Wyllie's reputation is well known and was to the fore in South Africa in 1970 and Britain and France in 1972-73 but most notably with Canterbury who enjoyed a fearsome reputation in the late-1960s and early 1970s as the Lions discovered in 1971.

Plantefol was the player who took on Colin Meads in the Test many All Blacks said was the toughest they ever played, against France on the 1967 tour. It was his actions that resulted in Meads wearing a prolific amount of bandaging under a scrum cap in the Test against Scotland a week later where he was ordered off.

Shaw was a handy player to have around when the going got willing during the mid-1980s while Morne du Plessis, the Springbok captain during the 1976 series against the All Blacks, was a constant menace among a very big pack, several of whom could also have joined the list.

Sebastian Chabal with his long hair and beard, and more than a little ability, was tough as teak and a fearsome player to run into, just ask Ali Williams who had his jaw broken in a clash.

When Colin Meads said Ken Gray was one of the strongest men he ever scrummaged with the commendation doesn't come much higher.

Mervyn Davies' contribution was an often forgotten part of the 1971 Lions' structure in their series win over the All Blacks. But his work at No 8 gave Gareth Edwards and Barry John the ride that allowed them to dictate their side's success.

Hooker Bismarck du Plessis wasn't afraid to mix it in all company while Kevin Skinner and Chris Koch had plenty of history in 1949 and 1956 to the point Skinner's involvement became folklore, even if Skinner maintained it wasn't as bad as was made out.

And it can be safely said that no one ever got the better of Keith Murdoch. Playing through a Test match and then being operated on for appendicitis says it all. His career was short but he made a big impact with his crowning glory his try in the 19-16 win over Wales that preceded his sending home.

Memory is selective and some of the toughest players are known only to their opponents, doing their job buried in the tight and winning little obvious recognition but gaining respect nonetheless.

Saturday, August 3, 2019

Sir Brian Lochore: Rugby greatness personified

In a sports-mad country like New Zealand, as a sports journalist, you get to mix and mingle with some outstanding sports people, who leave you with varying impressions.

It would be fair to say that Sir Brian Lochore will always be the measure by which assessment will be made. That's the very highest standard that others have to live up to.

Yet it was a standard that was completely natural and appeared to come with complete ease to a gentleman in all respects of the word. That's what made him the man he was.

Apart from my first exposure, as barely a high school student, to his ability to impart messages meaningfully at the Gore Wool Exchange when he and Colin Meads were invited, in early 1968, by the local Tin Hut Club to speak on their experiences on the 1967 tour of Britain, I next met him when he came south with Wairarapa Bush in their quest to relieve Southland of their place in the old National Provincial Championship in the promotion-relegation game of 1981.

A game Wairarapa Bush duly won to end one of the more harrowing seasons in Southland rugby history. That game was discussed many times over in subsequent meetings.

Transferring to Wellington there was considerably more contact with him, not so much in an active playing of the game sense – he had retired from coaching in 1987 – but in seeking opinions, comments and the like. It was also a time when he headed the Hillary Commission and it was in that respect that I saw the real Lochore mastery.

The New Zealand Sports Foundation, under its chief executive Chris Ineson, decided to host a "Captain's Forum" with as many of New Zealand's international sports captains who could possibly attend, as well as the Hillary Commission chairman, Sir Brian.

Held in Christchurch, it was an eye-opener and it was a privilege to be one of two sports journalists invited to attend. What transpired was a shocking indictment of sports administration in this country as captain after captain went through the process by which they had been appointed to their roles. The common denominator amongst them all was the complete lack of preparation they had followed by an absolute lack of support once they had accepted the role.

If ever there had been a need for a long, hard look at how these matters were handled this forum certainly provided it. Sir Brian sat through it all and offered various elements of wisdom from his own experience.

One gem he offered was that at his first pre-game team talk, before the first Test against the British & Irish Lions on their unfortunate tour of 1966, he had unleashed a torrent of swearing in trying to rev his players up. He recounted that afterwards Charlie Saxton, who would be the manager of the famed 1967 team, took him aside and told him that swearing wasn't necessary under those circumstances. He was the All Blacks captain and already had the respect of the players. Sir Brian commented to the captains that he had only sworn because that was what he thought was expected. But the word from Saxton set him on the straight and narrow and he never swore again in similar circumstances.

Lochore acknowledged after coach Sir Fred Allen's funeral in 2012 that his decision to appoint Lochore as captain had been life-changing, although he hadn't appreciated it at the time. Allen had gone for Lochore ahead of other more favoured contenders like: Colin Meads, Kel Tremain, Kel Tremain and Chris Laidlaw. And Allen said in later years that had been one of the master-strokes of his career.

It was interesting that while in a break during filming of a couple of interviews we did for the All Blacks Legends series for allblacks.com, Sir Brian related an interesting sequel to that night in Gore. He and Meads were staying in Invercargill where their wives were quartered but they returned home via central Southland where they called in on fellow 1967 team member Jack Hazlett's farm. Hazlett and a crew were hard at work taking full advantage of the long southern nights and warm weather to harvest some crops he had on his farm and they ended up working through the night to give Hazlett a hand, catching up with their wives the next morning.

Such a situation would surprise no one who knew either Lochore or Meads but it was typical of the qualities that made them such icons in the game.

What will be missed now that both men have been lost is the innate wisdom they so willingly shared, Meads in a more humorous sense and Lochore in regard for the legacy he loved and represented so willingly. 

Theirs has been a special generation in rugby and the game will do well to see their like repeated.

Monday, May 27, 2019

All Blacks pictures worth a thousand words

Black Boots – New Zealand's Rugby Legends, words by Phil Gifford, photographs by Barry Durrant and Morrie Hill, published by Bateman Books.

New Zealand's rugby history has traditionally been well served both in written and visual form and the latest offering Black Boots continues that legacy not only through the photographs of Barry Durrant but also the late Morrie Hill.

Writer Phil Gifford provides the mortar to their brickwork with his knowledgeable and authoritative captions, many of them classic vignettes in their own write (pardon the deliberate pun).

If rugby has changed since that day in 1995 when southern hemisphere rugby administrators bit the bullet and decided their future lay in a professional enterprise, then so too has the coverage.

Demands of commercialism and brands have seen photographic rights tied up and restricted and the sort of pictures included in this selection may never be seen when illustrating the modern era of the game.

The book is also representative of a more evocative, amateur age. 

The choice of Bryan 'Beegee' Williams on the cover stepping his way past a London Counties defender en route to the goalline, was a telling reminder of the frustration that attended Williams and many other backs during their careers. 

Inhibited by the damages caused the game by what was known as 10-man rugby played by New Zealand during the 1950s and for the first half of the 1960s, and as a default mechanism when things got tough in the 1970s, players of the quality of Williams had to wait their time to get a chance to do what they did best, run with the ball.

Williams had suggested a potential change in the All Blacks game on his brilliant tour of South Africa in 1970, a tour on which he set the rugby world alight with his speed, power and sidestep when barely out of his teens.

Yet New Zealand's rugby strategies of the day rarely allowed him the opportunity to show that quality again. That he scored only nine tries in 38 Tests was an indictment of the rugby played and the squandering of talent was all too common in that era.

At the same time, New Zealand produced some winning rugby and photos from both Durrant and Hill provide memories of some significant occasions.

Colin Meads, naturally, appears in many but was there ever a more representative photo of the skills he brought to the game than that from the outstanding 19-0 win over Wales at Lancaster Park in Christchurch? Ball tucked in his left hand, resting on his hip, he is looking to cut inside a defender while right on hand in support is prop Ken Gray with hooker Bruce McLeod behind.

Shots of crowds streaming out of the old Athletic Park after the second Test of the 1956 series with South Africa, are not only representative of the rugby of the era, but they are a snapshot of New Zealand society.

Another shot of a distressed loose forward John Graham being held by local medical men as they try to prevent him going back onto the field in the days when replacements for injuries were not allowed, is a reminder of the arcane practice of that era. 

Nowadays Graham would have been taken away for a head injury assessment and judging by the photograph would not have made it back onto the field. And he would have been replaced.

The concentration of photos are on the respective 1963-64 and 1972-73 tours of Britain, Ireland and France, because the two photographers covered one each of the tours, but there are many others from other years which round out a book which is another telling reminder of the legacy of rugby in New Zealand, but also of an enduring era in the game.

Saturday, June 24, 2017

Fifty years on from one of the great rugby tours

Much attention has focused on the 30-year anniversary of the first All Blacks team to win the Rugby World Cup in 1987, but also worthy of celebration is the 50-year anniversary of the 1967 All Blacks.

If the inaugural World Cup champions played a leading hand in revolutionising the way rugby was played in their time, then the honour of changing a fixation, and adapting quickest to new laws to speed up the game must go to Brian Lochore's side of 1967.

The side toured Britain and France, the Irish leg of their tour was cancelled due to a foot and mouth outbreak in England, and were unbeaten when living up to coach Fred Allen's statement at the beginning of the tour that they were going to run the ball and British and French fans should make sure they took the chance to watch them.

Their feats may seem like ancient history to the modern generation of rugby fans but to those who lived through their era they managed a revolution in the game and changed rugby forever.

It has become fashionable, especially in the midst of the 2017 British & Irish Lions tour, to claim the 1971 Lions had a huge impact on All Blacks rugby. To an extent they did, especially in scrummaging, and they did show, in their provincial games only, that it was possible to run the ball from everywhere.

But in terms of impact the fire was lit by Allen and Lochore's men, with not a little of assistance in terms of intent from tour manager and captain of the famous 1945-46 Kiwis Charlie Saxton.

Their mix created a huge impact in Britain and their feats have been recorded for the more recent rugby fan by Alex McKay in his book, The Team That Changed Rugby Forever – the 1967 All Blacks (Published by New Holland).

The coach of the 1971 Lions, Carwyn James and journalist John Reason, said in their 1979 book The World of Rugby, "…it was the statement of faith in 15-man attacking rugby, after years and years of ten-man attrition, that made the 1967 All Blacks so important in the development of the game."

They also added, "For at least 60 years, New Zealand had played in nothing like the same style, but by making such a commitment to attack, the 1967 All Blacks did the game of rugby football throughout the world a service which even they probably did not appreciate."

For British & Irish Lion and Wales flanker John Taylor was just at the start of his international career when playing for Wales against Lochore's team at Cardiff Arms Park and he recalled to the reviewer that he and his team-mates were well aware that they were facing something new in the game with the way the All Blacks were playing.

And while the score was only 13-6 to New Zealand in the Test Wales had been well beaten, he said.

McKay has set the scene for the tour by looking back at the time and the condition of rugby. He saw it from a close angle having often been a ball boy at Okara Park in his home town of Whangarei. In researching the book he travelled to New Zealand from his base in Australia and spoke with as many of the surviving players as he could.

Having worked in academia he wanted to write the story in a more free-writing style in telling the stories of what he was a diverse range of individuals who moulded into such a successful team.

After so many years he was impressed with how honest the players were.

"I was really impressed with them, I didn't expect that," he said.

They had been a literal Band of Brothers and he felt a central part of their story was what they had done after their careers was over. In the case of the 1967 side it is a remarkable contribution to the game.

Lochore's subsequent deeds are well known and are reflected in his position as patron of New Zealand Rugby. But others like: Earle Kirton, Ian Kirkpatrick, Colin Meads, Graham Williams, Alistair Hopkinson, Waka Nathan and Sid Going had significant coaching careers while others like Malcolm Dick, Ian MacRae, Kel Tremain and Meads again had been involved at a high level of administration.

Chris Laidlaw, Tony Steel, Ken Gray and Grahame Thorne went on to careers as politicians while Jack Hazlett had a significant career in business. Bill Davis also represented New Zealand at softball.

All of this is revealed by McKay and demonstrates why this was such a special side and deserving of a revered place in New Zealand rugby history.

McKay has left no stone unturned and it is significant that he has highlighted that not everyone in the side was enamoured with Allen and his methods, which is a healthy balance in any appreciation.

The story of the side deserves a special place in New Zealand's burgeoning rugby literature and McKay has filled a significant gap in that regard.

The presentation of the book is effective, if disappointing for the number of errors not detected in proof-reading, but that aside it captures its subject splendidly and that after all was its aim.


The Team That Changed Rugby Forever – the 1967 All Blacks by Alex McKay. Published by New Holland, Price $35.00

Monday, July 7, 2014

The first great All Blacks' streak 1965-69

Should Richie McCaw's All Blacks achieve their 18th consecutive Test win, against Australia in Sydney, on August 16, the significance of their feat will be to surpass one of the great teams of New Zealand rugby.

Under the guidance of coaching supremo Fred Allen, for all but the last two games of their 17-Test winning run from 1965-1969, the team which was largely led by No.8 Brian Lochore, beat France four times, Australia three, the British and Irish Lions four, Wales three and South Africa, England and Scotland once. Had a foot and mouth disease outbreak in England not occurred during the 1967 tour of Britain, Ireland and France, a hastily-arranged tour in lieu of New Zealand's declining a tour to South Africa, the streak may have extended to 18 as the Test match against Ireland was cancelled.

Thirty-eight players were involved in the streak, only one of them Colin Meads, playing in all 17 games.

Hooker Bruce McLeod played 16 missing only the 75th Jubilee Test, against Australia at Athletic Park in 1967, to break his sequence.

Lochore, who captained the team in 14 of the games, played in 15 of the matches. He assumed the captaincy after Wilson Whineray's retirement following what was the first game of the streak against South Africa at Eden Park, a 20-3 victory in 1965. 

Lochore's absence from two Tests was the result of an injury suffered in the first Test against Australia in Sydney in 1968, an injury which saw Ian Kirkpatrick become New Zealand's first replacement in a Test match following the IRB's law change allowing injured players to be replaced. Kirkpatrick marked the occasion by scoring a hat-trick of tries.

Apart from Lochore and Whineray, the captaincy was also in the hands of halfback Chris Laidlaw and flanker Kel Tremain for a Test each.

Three players made 13 appearances, Tremain, prop Ken Gray and second five-eighths Ian MacRae.

The full list of players to play during the streak was: (Tests in brackets) 
Fergie McCormick (12), 
Bill Birtwistle (4), 
Ron Rangi (5), 
I.S.T. Smith (4), 
John Collins (1), 
Mack Herewini (6), 
Chris Laidlaw (12), 
Brian Lochore (15), 
Red Conway (1), 
Stan Meads (5), 
Colin Meads (17), 
Kel Tremain (13), 
Ken Gray (13), 
Bruce McLeod (16), 
Wilson Whineray (1), 
Mick Williment (5), 
Tony Steel (9), 
Ian MacRae (13), 
Waka Nathan (5), 
Jack Hazlett (6), 
Malcolm Dick (7), 
Bill Davis (10), 
Sid Going (5), 
Sam Strahan (10), 
Jazz Muller (7), 
John Major (1), 
Earle Kirton (11), 
Graham Williams (5), 
Ian Kirkpatrick (8), 
Alister Hopkinson (6), 
Alan Smith (2), 
Tony Kreft (1), 
Grahame Thorne (6), 
Wayne Cottrell (4), 
Owen Stephens (1), 
Tom Lister (5), 
Mick O'Callaghan (3), 
George Skudder (1).

The side scored 54 tries (when they were still worth three points) in their 17 games with wing Steel, a national sprint champion in New Zealand, touching down seven times while Ian Kirkpatrick scored five tries.

McCormick scored 112 points from 23 conversions and 21 penalty goals and one dropped goal while Mick Williment scored 51 points from a try, 12 conversions and eight penalty goals.

Here's how the streak was made up:

Test 1 - v South Africa, Eden Park, September 18, 1965, Won 20-3

This came after the humiliating 16-19 loss at Lancaster Park when New Zealand turned 16-5 ahead at half-time and looking set to clean sweep the Springboks. But brilliant second five-eighths John Gainsford and fine wing Gert Brynard scored two tries apiece while big lock Tiny Naude had landed a penalty goal out of the mud to secure a fine win. Stung by their loss, the All Blacks made the most of spring conditions to run in five tries, two of them to wing I.S.T. 'Spooky' Smith. Had new cap Fergie McCormick had his goal-kicking boots on the humiliation could have been even greater. He converted only one of the tries.

Critical comment: AC Parker, Now Is The Hour, "There was certainly nothing in the first half to suggest that the All Blacks would, in the end, triumph by a staggering 17-points margin - one that equalled South Africa's 17-0 win over the Kiwis in the first test of the 1928 series in Durban."

Test 2 - v British and Irish Lions, Carisbrook, July 16, 1966, Won 20-3

The Lions had endured a terrible build-up to this Test having lost the first game of their tour to Southland, and then following that with losses to Otago and Wellington, while they had also drawn with Bay of Plenty. Playing under Brian Lochore's captaincy for the first time New Zealand scored three tries to none, including one to the skipper for a comfortable win. Debuting in the game were Ian McRae, Jack Hazlett and Tony Steel.

Critical Comment: T.P. McLean, The Lion Tamers, "The All Blacks this afternoon won the first test by 20 points to 3 and if Mack Herewini had not kicked so much in the second half, they would have won by 30 points, perhaps even 40, so decisively superior were they."

Test 3 - v British and Irish Lions, Athletic Park, August 6, 1966, Won 16-12

Six changes were made by the Lions, it had been seven but Ray McLoughlin was forced out with the 'flu on the morning of the match and it was to prove their best Test performance of the tour. In spite of the muddy conditions the sides attempted to move the ball but it was only New Zealand who could score the tries with Kel Tremain, Colin Meads and Tony Steel crossing the line. Video coverage available here

Critical Comment: Brian O'Brien, Sports Digest, "The test rubber is well and truly lost because the British Isles team has been short on too many simple fundamentals of forward - and back - play."

Test 4 - v British and Irish Lions, Lancaster Park, August 27, 1966, Won 19-6

The Lions were at sixes and sevens as was seen by their decision to play Delme Thomas, a lock, in the front row. However, the Lions held the All Blacks to 6-6 at half-time. And if there had been better support for Mike Gibson, the superb Lions second five-eighths there might have been more reward for the Lions. As it was Steel was put in the clear to score the All Blacks first try, and Waka Nathan's support play was rewarded with two later tries.

Critical Comment: J.B.G. Thomas, Western Mail, "The bad luck that has dogged them throughout the tour was with them again and time after time they were just denied scores…the rub of the green never once went the Lions' way."

Test 5 - v British and Irish Lions, Eden Park, September 10, 1966, Won 24-11

The fourth Test was notable for New Zealand making the only change to their playing XV in the four-match series when Malcolm Dick replaced I.S.T. Smith on the wing. The quick-thinking of the All Blacks was apparent in the opening try of the game when Lions wing Dewi Bebb took the ball into touch just out from the Lions' line. Colin Meads was onto the ball in a flash and threw it in quickly to Nathan who scored the easiest of tries with the Lions caught completely off-guard. Three more followed to Dick, MacRae and Steel before a comfortable match and series win was achieved. Video coverage available here

Critical Comment: T.P. McLean, The Lion Tamers, "Once more the triumph was the performance of the All Black forwards - all of them. Meads, Meads, Gray, Hazlett, McLeod and Lochore in the tight stuff, Tremain and Nathan in the loose, swooped and swarmed and battered and harried."

Test 6 - v Australia (75th Jubilee Test), Athletic Park, August 19, 1967, Won 29-9

This was a Test match which once and for all highlighted the potency Fred Allen was developing in his side. That was all the more surprising given the new blood introduced. Sid Going played his first Test at halfback while Bill Davis, a 1963-64 tourist to Britain, came in a centre with Sam Strahan at lock, Brian 'Jazz' Muller and Jack Hazlett as props while hooker John Major played his only Test. Three tries in six minutes in the third quarter, to Bill Davis, Steel and Tremain took the game away from a gallant Australian team before Steel had a chance to put his sprinting ability to use to score a second.

Critical Comment: Max Howell, Lingyu Xie, Bensley Wilkes, The Wallabies, "It was an exhilarating performance worthy of the best traditions of the game."

Test 7 - v England, Twickenham, November 4, 1967, Won 23-11

Earle Kirton marked his Test debut, and return to the top-flight of the game after a harrowing tour in 1963-64, by scoring two tries in this Twickenham thriller, the second of which was a superb run on the angle into the corner. New Zealand lead 18-5 at half-time and while scoring only one more try they were well on top of the old foe in claiming a record winning margin over them. Also making his debut in the game was Graham Williams, one of the forgotten men in this streak. His chance to play came after Waka Nathan had his jaw broken for the second time on a tour of England. Video coverage available here

Critical Comment: Vivian Jenkins, The Sunday Times (England): "All three [tries] demonstration the New Zealanders' mastery of the basic skills of handling and passing, even in these extremely difficult conditions. In addition there was the never-ending forward surge and impetus of their mighty pack. This is a great New Zealand side without a doubt, and anyone who beats them will truly earn a place in the Hall of Fame."

Test 8 - v Wales, Cardiff Arms Park, November 11, 1967, Won 13-6

Conditions were bleak for this encounter, a typically dour struggle as Wales still gave themselves every chance of claiming an All Black scalp. They paired halfback Gareth Edwards and first five-eighths Barry John for the first time in a Test. But in spite of the conditions New Zealand's willingness to move the ball saw Davis show his class with an outside break which provided just enough room for Birtwistle to score in the corner. McCormick landed a superb conversion from the sideline. The conditions contributed to Wales' demise when a long-range penalty attempt by McCormick had unexpected rewards. The shot fell short but after fielding the ball, Wales' No.8 John Jeffery inexplicably threw the ball over his shoulder - to no-one. Davis had pursued the kick and in the resulting melee got to the ball first for what was the match-winning try.

Critical Comment: J.B.G. Thomas, Rugby in Black and Red, "New Zealand were much the better side and, although mud is always a great leveller, one would not remember the match as a genuine challenge to the supremacy of the world champions…To win in Test rugby you must kick your goals, take your chances and make no errors. This sums up, more than adequately, the Wales v New Zealand match of 1967."

Test 9 - v France, Colombes Stadium, November 25, 1967, Won 21-15

Talk to any of the All Blacks involved and they will comment on the ferocity of this encounter. Colin Meads was targeted by the French and suffered a bad gash to his head. Up 11-9 at half-time, the All Blacks went behind when Pierre Villepreux landed a penalty goal. Only 15 minutes remained when the winning advantage was secured after Sid Going made precisely the sort of break he had been selected for. Support from Meads was enough for him to feed Ian Kirkpatrick, whose present on debut was a broken nose in the first five minutes, in for his first Test try. Dick scored another afterwards to make the game safe but it had been one of the toughest encounters of the streak.

Critical Comment: Hacques Carducci, Le Journal du Dimanche, "A film director could not have devised a better scenario. In turn, violent, agonising, thrilling, beautiful, revolting, this match will remain in the annals as the most tremendous set-to to have taken place on the green sward of Colombes for 15 years."

Test 10 - v Scotland, Murrayfield, December 2, 1967, Won 14-3

Scotland were seen as a potential banana skin for the tourists as New Zealand hadn't been able to score a try against them since their 1935-36 tour. But a Willie Away movement which saw Meads, obvious on the day due to the head bandage he was wearing as a result of the wound suffered in Paris, created the room for McRae to score the first try. Up 9-3 at half-time, it wasn't until the 75th minute that New Zealand made the game safe, courtesy of an Earle Kirton double round which created space for Bill Davis to score. Sadly, in the last few minutes of the game the success was outdone by the ordering off of Meads by referee Kevin Kelleher for dangerous play following a warning he had received earlier in the game.

Critical Comment: Michael Melford, The Sunday Telegraph, "Some may think that he [Meads] has been lucky to sail near the wind for so long and survive, but there is a stigma attached to being sent off which made the decision as this stage of an orderly match desperately harsh, especially to a member of a team which has overall done all it can to advertise the skills of New Zealand Rugby [sic] rather than the toughness."

Test 11 - v Australia, Sydney Cricket Ground, June 15, 1968, Won 27-11

Fred Allen started to introduce his next crop of players on the tour to Australia in 1968 and that was seen in the naming of the first Test side which saw Grahame Thorne on the wing, although he had previously played at centre while Tom Lister was included on the side of the scrum. But was the loss of captain Lochore a few minutes into the Test with a broken thumb that was to prove of most consequence. His replacement Ian Kirkpatrick scored a hat-trick of tries in a game that became most notable for the horrific injury suffered by ace Australian halfback Ken Catchpole who was pulled from a ruck by Colin Meads who hadn't realised Catchpole's leg was pinned. The pulled muscles and tendons resulted in Catchpole never playing again.

Critical Comment: Dick Tucker, The Sunday Mirror, "The All Blacks were caught unawares by Australian coach Des O'Connor's [sic] plan of conceding them the ball from the line outs and scrums and then hitting their backs hard and fast to jar the ball loose. The All Blacks won the line out ball all right, but their backs collected a green and gold jumper at about the same time as the ball. It was adventurous planning to counter the tourists' line out dominance."

Test 12 - v Australia, Ballymore, June 22, 1968, Won 19-18

Des Conner had been one of the key men in Fred Allen's Ranfurly Shield side of the early 1960s but he did him no favours as Australian coach, and especially in this game in which he continued his policy of using reduced numbers in the  line outs ploy caused all manner of frustrations for the All Blacks. Australia were up 12-11 at half-time. It was midway through the second half before Thorne scored his try on debut, but with Arthur McGill having landed one of five penalty goals in the game, New Zealand were still behind. Things looked desperate with two minutes to go. At that point Bill Davis put a kick ahead to the Australian in-goal area, but just after making the kick and following up, he was tackled by Barry Honan and the referee Kevin Crowe immediately signalled a penalty try to New Zealand. McCormick's easy conversion from in front of the posts allowed the All Blacks to scrape out to keep their streak intact.

Critical Comment: Frank O'Callaghan, The Sunday Mail, "I never thought I would see an All Black side panic, but panic they did. They seemed stunned by the fanatical fervour of the Australian defence."

Test 13 - v France, Lancaster Park, July 13, 1968, Won 12-9

Knowing what to expect as a result of their battle in Colombes seven months earlier, the All Blacks were prepared, albeit without some experienced men. The scores were tied 3-3 at halftime and as a dull game wound down it appeared a draw would be the outcome. However, just before full-time was blown, a French scrum close to their line saw a poor pass from halfback Marcel Puget to fullback Villepreux roll along the ground. Villepreux soccer-kicked it for touch. However, it hit Thorne's shoulder and rebounded in-goal where a mad scramble saw the ball bounce off Tremain's head annd fly free for Kirton to skid in to touch down for the try. Video coverage available here

Critical Comment: Alex Veysey, The Sunday Times: "When all the other things about this game are forgotten, the 36 penalties, the arguments about their justification, the mud, even New Zealand's death-knock try to win the game, it will be remembered as the day when French rugby proved itself to a sceptical New Zealand public."            
Test 14 - v France, Athletic Park, July 27, 1968, Won 9-3

Two memories abound of this game, the niggly attitude which resulted in little clear-cut rugby being played and the monstrous penalty landed by Villepreux from nearly five metres inside his own half and well towards the sideline. Laughter from the Athletic Park cognoscenti greeted his decision to try for goal but that was soon turned to amazement when it flew over the cross bar to give France a 3-0 lead at half-time. New Zealand turned on the power in the second half and while they couldn't cross the French line, Fergie McCormick found his goal-kicking touch to land three penalty goals for a 9-3 win. Significantly, the French lost their yapping halfback Puget, the captain on the day, to an injury and he flew home soon after the game. He was one of the main belligerents in the unhappy atmosphere in the game. 

Critical Comment: Graeme Jenkins, NZPA, "It should have been champagne Rugby when New Zealand and France met in the second test at Athletic Park on Saturday. Instead, it was a fairly insipid, if not downright sour, brew with the All Blacks winning 9-3."

Test 15 - v France, Eden Park, August 10, 1968, Won 19-12

A much better attitude was witnessed in this game which became a fitting farewell for coach Fred Allen as both teams opened up their running game, France inspired by the move of Jo Maso from centre to first five-eighths. France, outscored New Zealand three tries to two, but the New Zealand decision to change halfbacks proved crucial. Sid Going was given licence to run by Allen and he punished the French with two tries in one of his finest games for the side.

Critical Comment: Adrian Clarke, The Sunday Times (NZ), "I thought the All Blacks played ideal All Black rugby in the first half. Colin Meads was outstanding. I don't think I have ever seen one man in so much of the game all the time. Sid Going had a great game. It was the best half-back exhibition I have seen since Des Connor retired."

Test 16 - v Wales, Lancaster Park, May 31, 1969, Won 19-0
Wales came to New Zealand as Five Nations champions but made a fatal mistake in accepting only one game before the first Test, against Taranaki. The All Blacks were playing under a new coach Ivan Vodanovich but played in the manner they had shown on their 1967 tour and Wales had no answer. In what would become a forerunner of the modern All Blacks, it was prop forward Jazz Muller and hooker Bruce McLeod who cut the early capers to upset the Welsh. A superb sprint by Muller opened space for McLeod who galloped 20m to score the second of the All Blacks' tries. Malcolm Dick, Brian Lochore and Ken Gray would also score in a comprehensive New Zealand win.

Critical Comment: Clem Thomas, The Sunday Times: "In all my experience I can never recall a Welsh pack receiving such a father and mother of a hiding as it did at Lancaster Park on Saturday. Furthermore, I cannot recall any pack of forwards playing as well as this all Black pack."

Test 17 - v Wales, Eden Park, June 14, 1969, Won 33-12

They wrote a song about this match, and especially Fergie McCormick as he scored 24 points to claim the world record for most points by an individual in a game from three conversions, five penalty goals and a dropped goal. But the Welsh had their own hero in wing Maurice Richards who scored a superb try only to be lost to rugby league soon after. George Skudder scored a try, notable for the spectacular dive he executed, while Ian MacRae and Ian Kirkpatrick also scored for the All Blacks. The match was the beginning of the end for New Zealand. Ken Gray said he would not tour South Africa and he retired from Test rugby while Kel Tremain was dropped for the series. Want to know more about the All Blacks of this era? Click here, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4


Critical Comment: Alex Veysey, The Sunday Times: "Wales went into the game with high hopes for a prestige victory to take home. The champions of the five nations plummeted to a defeat which for them was indeed a tragedy. They seemed both dumbfounded and angry by the day's events."