Monday, September 7, 2015

New book offers complete history of New Zealand's game

For all the wealth of information committed to print in the last 125 years regarding New Zealand rugby, a complete history has always been conspicuous by its absence.

New rugby history offers complete story of the NZ game
Whether it was because rugby was just a game and therefore not worth the attention of any academic, or because the sort of people who played rugby were not the sort to be interested in all that had gone before, or any of the dismissive attitudes that invariably raise their heads when attention to rugby outweighs the emphasis that is perceived as not being paid to the arts and other endeavours, there remained a hole in the reference area that captured its complete history.

That has changed with Dr Ron Palenski's 'Rugby: A New Zealand History'. It tells the story of the game that, in spite of what some may believe, has captured the interest of New Zealanders like no other.

Palenski is part of a growing community, not only in the academic sphere but across the board, who appreciate that rugby is more than a game and it is beginning to take its place as an attachment worth far more than passing treatment it has received in the past. And the same attitude is applying to sport in general.

Management treatises of the virtues to be had in acknowledging the astonishing winning success rate the nation's top team, the All Blacks, have achieved in international play are becoming common.

Universities are starting to include Sport History papers in their offerings to students and people like Palenski are lending an academic approach to aspects of the game that have tended to be the area of newspaper journalists and enthusiasts who have recorded the development of the game through the various provinces that support the game in New Zealand. Theses are being written about aspects of the development of the game and academic journals have many more papers associated with rugby than was previously the case.

Palenski was one of the most influential sports journalists in the country before joining the exodus of much of the institutional sports experience associated with newspapers in New Zealand to pursue an academic career - the end result of which is a doctorate and a historian's approach to the subject that has occupied much of his twin careers.

The result is the long awaited history of the game represented in his latest book. It is not stretching the point too far to say that Rugby: A New Zealand History is Palenski's finest work.

He had already put to bed the myth that a printer or sub-editor's error in England was responsible for giving the All Blacks their name. But he reaffirms that research in this book, along with many other myths that have grown up.

One of these is the claim that a New Zealander, William Atack, gave the whistle by which referees now control games, to rugby in 1884. Palenski shows that claim may have been true in New Zealand, but evidence exists that a whistle was used in Australia a year earlier.

It is interesting also that while Robbie Deans was believed to be the first New Zealander to coach Australia the facts show that when Australia played their first Test, against Great Britain in 1899, the coach of the Australian side was Billy Warbrick, one of the famous New Zealand family who had been associated with the New Zealand Natives side to Britain, Australia and New Zealand in 1888-89.

Snippets on various aspects of the game, including music, warfare connections, political interest, art, the origins of the Bledisloe Cup and a wealth of others, are the subject of breakout stories in the text and provide a complete picture of the game and its moods.

It would be difficult to imagine that 'new' photographs might be available but there are many that capture aspects of the game through the years that enhance the text superbly.

By its nature, the book spends much time on the years preceding the 1970s. This is not surprising. The years previous were the time in which the legend was formulated and information of more recent times is often not so readily available, for any number of reasons, including closeness to events, and a lack of total perspective around modern happenings.

Understanding those nuances in the game will be the task of future historians, but those same historians will be able to rest assured that they have a significant foundation to work from on.

Nothing is ever a closed book, and there will be elements arise that are not included in Palenski's book, but they will be few and far between so well has the history been accounted for in this publication.

'Rugby: A New Zealand History' is the history the game deserves.

Rugby: A New Zealand History by Ron Palenski. Published by Auckland University Press.



Thursday, June 11, 2015

Peter Petherick, a long wait made worthwhile

Peter Petherick's death in Perth this week brought to mind the realisation that the prospect of late developers getting an opportunity in cricket are more likely the exception rather than the rule in the modern era.

Petherick, an off-spinner, who took a hat-trick on his Test debut – one of only three players to achieve the feat, had a long wait before being called out of Central Otago, at the age of 33, for the first-class summer of 1974-75.

He took 42 wickets, in a stunning debut season, and was selected for New Zealand's tour of Pakistan and India in 1976.

In an interview with Petherick, who had by that stage moved to Paraparaumu, for Wellington's Evening Post he told me he had never given up hope of playing first-class cricket.

"I was just waiting. Jack and Gren Alabaster were dominating things down south. But I was always keen to play first-class cricket because you don't know your limitations until you play at that level.

"It's the same when you move up to Test level," he said.

Not that the transition to first-class play from the Hawke Cup cricket he had been playing was any jaunt.

Petherick was so concerned two weeks before his first match, against Canterbury, that he rang Glenn Turner for some advice. Turner invited him down to his Dunedin home to stay until the game.

"I knew I could do well because I could turn the ball. But Glenn got me to move my line over from off stump to middle and leg. I took three of the four wickets to fall in Otago's first game before rain set in and I was right," he said.

Then making his Test debut in Lahore he found himself wicketless for 96 runs and wishing he was away back home in Central Otago.

The only comfort to him was that he was getting slaughtered just like all the New Zealand bowlers.

"That's the thing over there. You can bowl a lot of maidens but then you can concede a lot of 12-run overs," he said.

But just when things looked darkest, a spot of light shone on his misery.

"Javed Miandad and Asif Iqbal had recovered the Pakistan innings but then just before tea, Javed tried to put a ball over the fence and got only a top edge to Richard Hadlee standing by the square leg umpire."

Petherick had a notable first wicket in Test matches.

"Wasim Raja was next in and came down the wicket. I was bowling around the wicket to him and he hit it straight back to me for the caught-and-bowled.

"Intikhab Alam came in and I never even thought about the hat-trick. The players were crowding the bat.

"As I went back to my mark I thought to myself, 'If I was Intikhab Alam I would come down the wicket' and so I darted one in to him. He got a glove or a hand to it and Geoff Howarth made a great catch.

"Everyone appealed and as I turned around to the umpire he was unmoved.

"I thought he wasn't going to give it, but then his finger went up.

"However, it was only after Intikhab had walked that he did it," he said.

Rajah and Intikhab had not been named in the side originally and when they were dismissed the crowd went crazy because one of their players had been left out of the side.

Petherick had his own version of umpiring abilities in Pakistan and they weren't related to the reluctance of the umpire to give a decision on his hat-trick ball.

"At one stage I was batting with Andy Roberts and I was out three times, but not given. Then when I was given out, it wasn't out.

"The umpires were not cheats, they were quite nice people and were under a hell of a lot of pressure, they were just incompetent."


Petherick played six Tests for New Zealand, taking 16 wickets at 42.81. In first-class play of 52 matches he took 189 wickets at 24.47 with a best performance of 9-93.

Tuesday, April 21, 2015

Change of flag is timely and natural

Changing the New Zealand flag is well overdue.

There it is out and said.

The debate about whether New Zealand should throw off the cloak of her colonial past, because that is what the existing flag represents, is healthy and timely.

In spite of those who would say the money spent in a referendum could be better spent elsewhere, the debate is a worthy one.

And there are plenty of other funding choices the government has that could be better spent elsewhere so that argument is a red herring and only clouding the issue, conveniently so for those who don't want change.

The Returned Services Association has been to the fore in opposition to a referendum stating the country's services went to war under the flag and that was what they fought for.

Really?

The servicemen who fought in World War One answered the call of Empire. But it has been acknowledged that the King wasn't foremost in their thoughts. In many, if not most, instances they fought for their mates. They fought for survival and to be able to walk tall when returning from war for the contribution they made to the effort. And they had the chance to go on an adventure that would not otherwise have been available to them.

Some went unwillingly, the victims of anonymous white feathers in the mail that signalled they were cowardly for not playing their part.

In World War Two there was a more obvious reason given the aggression of Germany, her expansion plans and, subsequently, the expansionist plans of her Pacific ally Japan.

The New Zealanders of the First World War were not an autonomous unit. They were commanded by British generals whose follies are represented in the Gallipoli campaign which is at the core of the Anzac Day commemoration every April 25. That's not to forget the Passchendaele campaign organised by generals who had never visited the boggy marshes in which men were expected to fight.

By the Second World War New Zealand demanded that autonomy and that was achieved under the guardianship of General Bernard Freyberg, in league with the Prime Minister Peter Fraser.

But it is worth remembering the follies imposed on the forces at Anzac were rolled out again in 1941 when ill-equipped, poorly-supported and under-manned forces were sent into Greece in a hopeless bid to stop Axis expansion.

Those involved in getting New Zealand and Australia to take part were involved in deceit of the highest order, informing General Freyberg their plans had the assent of the New Zealand Government. That had only occurred because the New Zealand Government had been told Freyberg was in agreement.

The result? Another fine mess that resulted in New Zealand's Division almost being wiped out in Crete before the war had hardly begun. The British Middle East command, known as the 'Muddle East', refused to acknowledge New Zealand's demand to fight as an individual unit and until Freyberg put his foot down attempts were made to pick off various units for work that suited the British.

It should also not be forgotten that after years of saying New Zealand's security would be protected by the Royal Naval base in Singapore, to which New Zealand contributed significant amounts of money, that even before the second world war had started the British had decided they couldn't protect Australia and New Zealand – although they declined to tell either country.

There are numerous other instances of sufficient concern to say that not everyone shares the RSA's feeling toward the Mother Country and the link they would retain to her through the continuation of the Union Jack being represented in a New Zealand flag.

Having contributed so much to the war effort, not only in manpower, but also in food production, New Zealand then found herself cast aside and left to fight for herself when Britain aligned herself with the European Community.

Was that what the New Zealand soldiers fought for? Is that why we should cherish the Union Jack on our flag?
 
Check out any photos of New Zealand involvement in the Second World War. Vehicles all showed a silver fern. The New Zealand badge had two silver ferns in its design. Signposts of New Zealand encampments all had silver ferns on them.

Why? Because they were distinct from British and Australian logos. They were distinctive of New Zealand.

Visit any war graves from the first and second world wars, and the New Zealand headstones will be easily recognisable with their fern design.

New Zealand is an autonomous country, its silver fern is already well known and it should be the centrepiece of a black flag. And claiming it could be confused with the Isis flag is hogwash. New Zealand's sports uniform has been all black with the silver fern since the 1890s. Is that connection to be denied because it clashes with a johnny-come-lately fanatical group?


New Zealand was forced to find its way in the world in spite of her allegiance to Britain and all the lives that were laid down in rightful causes. It is now time to recognise that and strike out a new flag, a flag that is aspirational and built on a legacy of sacrifice not only by the armed services but by citizens from all walks of life.

Monday, April 13, 2015

Sharks paying the price of player power

Player power appears to have rebounded on the struggling Sharks in Super Rugby this year.

South African journalist Mark Keohane said the departure of former Springboks coach Jake White after only one season with the club was the result of players wanting him out.

Under White the Sharks had won the South African Conference, won two games in New Zealand and three on their Australasian tour and included a first win over the Crusaders in Christchurch.

They were beaten by the Crusaders in the semi-finals. During the 2014 season they conceded 22 tries. But in 2015 they conceded that many in only eight games.

However, the players said he was too much of a disciplinarian who demanded the players report at 8.30 each day for work.

It was reported that there was also a clash in the coaching support given to White by Sharks chief executive and former Springbok captain John Smit. White wasn't prepared to work with Brad MacLeod-Henderson and Paul Anthony who had less than a year of professional coaching experience between them.

White believed the Sharks, with the quality of their squad, their budget and the strength of their brand, should have performed better in the competition and believed only a change of culture would change the results, Keohane said.

After White's departure the franchise's Currie Cup team suffered a 50-point thrashing in the semi-finals but they were retained and joined by Gary Gold just before the start of the Super Rugby season after he had completed a coaching commitment with a Japanese team.

Keohane said: "Smit, Gold and the players don't agree that the Sharks are a squad in crisis. It's all smiles within the group in Durban and the leadership has been dismissive of critique around the coaching appointments and player recruitment."


Meanwhile White, coaching Montpellier in France, has seen his side in with a chance of making the play-offs. His key weapons? Discipline and defence.

Who will win out in the end? At the moment the Sharks are ninth on the ladder, and fourth of the South African sides with one of the worst disciplinary records in the competition.



Perhaps White was right.

Sanzar cop more strife, from within their camp

South African rugby boss Oregan Hoskins has launched a broadside at inconsistencies in disciplinary rulings in Super Rugby.

Hoskins said South African players were being harder hit by the judiciary than New Zealand and Australian players. He had made his objections 'loud and clear' at an emergency meeting with key figures in judicial and disciplinary structures.

Hoskins said the decisions against Bismarck du Plessis (four weeks), Frans Steyn (five weeks) and Jean Deysel (seven weeks) were heavy compared to those against Australasian players.

He cited Reds lock James Horwill's second red card of the season and the one week he received for a swinging arm on a player's neck, Reds flanker Liam Gill's one match suspension for a tip tackle and Hurricanes lock James Broadhurst's one week for kneeing a player in the face.

Hoskins said he hadn't wanted to speak out but told South African rugby writer Dan Retief he had had enough.

"I feel we, as administrators, are fighting one fight and do not have the support of our judicial and refereeing panels.

"To be absolutely honest with you, I am at my wits-end, because I am seeing how we are being torn apart on the field of play and by judicial decisions, and we are not getting the support we should be getting from these people, who are part of our organisation [Sanzar]," he said.

Hoskins was at the Sharks-Crusaders match and claimed there were several incidents against Sharks players that had gone unpunished.

While Deysel had done a 'stupid thing' in kneeing Matt Todd in the head, it wasn't injurious, he said.

"But still, it's not allowed, and he got a red card and a heavy suspension, while the others were not even cited," he said.


Meanwhile, South Afric's referees' boss Andre Watson has appeared in front of a disciplinary hearing after a list of grievances, including verbal abuse, victimisation and his abrasive management style were made against him by 24 local officials.